When I used "analyze" on defrag, I saw something that I've never seen before.
There were really thick red stripes......it darn near looked like awning stripes....lol. It said I should defrag, so I did. Then it told me that there were 8,258 fragments that could not be defragged.
There's a few files that the XP defrag tool won't be able to defrag:
System volume information
System Restore points
Pagefile
You could remove all but the latest system restore point to free up space:
Select Start, All Programs, Accessories, System Tools, Disk CleanUp, More Options, System Restore and remove all but the latest restore point.
The amount of free space is important when running Disk Defragmenter. A minimum of 15% is required but sometimes more to cope with more large files.
You can run Disk Defragmenter a second and third time if files are still fragmented after the first run.
If you use Outlook Express compacting folders before running Disk Defragmenter may help.
I just did a system restore.....defragged again , rebooted and nothing changed. The files that I put in folders are still in them...I thought the restore may put everything back the way it was?
Restore deals mostly with registry, not data. So, any folders with your own data in them won't be touched. Programs you installed will after the system restore point will be removed though.
I saved the "report" and its showing a backup file that I made on 3-20-08 as the file that can't be defragged. So I went to search, and looked for it.....
What report is that? The defrag report?
I clicked it and a file restore "wizard" came up so I let it restore the files. I tried to defrag again, and it stopped and said that these files are a different version than the originals and to fix this I have to insert a CD? It doesn't even say which one? Maybe XP?
Without knowing what the report was, I couldn't say. I am guessing that you have run a system file check - and reporting that some files are different versions is normal because you will have updated many files through normal Windows updates. You shouldn't, normally, replace any.
I think you should be trying one more system restore to before you started 'tinkering' and ensure that your system is working OK before trying anything else.